The latest research and tests on this continued threat posed to horses
Atypical Myopathy (AM), also referred to as Seasonal Pasture Myopathy (SPM), often results in a rapid deterioration of the horse’s health with reports indicating a 75-90% mortality rate1,2. Numerous research studies have found that AM is highly associated with the ingestion of sycamore seeds, leaves and seedlings which have been found, in varying concentrations, to contain a substance called Hypoglycin-A3. This substance poses a huge problem for horses, as it is converted into a toxin within the horse’s body4. The toxin has a rapid negative effect on the normal functioning of the horse’s cells, as it deprives the horse’s muscle fibres of the energy it needs to work.
During the spring months, The British Horse Society urges all horse owners to be vigilant for sycamore seedlings. Be aware that the sycamore seed, more commonly known as ‘helicopter seeds’ can land between 30 and 80 metres from its parent tree, but in strong winds can travel several kilometres5. As a result, seedlings can appear to grow in areas which aren’t surrounded by sycamore trees.
The postural (muscles responsible for keeping the horse standing) and respiratory (breathing) muscles are most commonly affected and, therefore, the clinical signs shown by the horse most often reflect muscular problems, signs associated with pain and breathing difficulties. The onset of AM is rapid and horses can quickly deteriorate within 6-12 hours4. As the toxin’s effects progress, the horse’s heart muscle can also be affected.
A recent study6 compared the respiratory capacity of 15 horses diagnosed with AM against 10 healthy horses. The study concluded that the horses with AM showed up to a 49% decrease in their respiratory capacity compared to the healthy horses. This highlights the severe internal changes in the horse and how this contributes to the high mortality rate associated with the disease.
The sycamore tree belongs to the Acer family group. In the UK, the most common Acer family trees are the field maple, sycamore maple and the Norway maple. Numerous studies continue to investigate the Hypoglycin-A levels in all of these trees, but so far have found that the field and Norway maple do not contain this substance7,8 and, therefore, is currently related to sycamore trees1, 9-11. The box elder tree, which is native to North America, also contains Hypoglycin-A and is linked to causing SPM. Hypoglycin-A was first found in this tree’s plant material and due to the similarities of SPM and AM this was the reason researchers began to investigate European Acer trees and their potential link to causing AM1.
For many horse owners in the UK, the sycamore tree is a common and attractive feature in paddocks used to graze horses. The fact that sycamore trees now pose a risk to horses may come as a surprise to many horse owners whose animals have been happily grazing alongside sycamore trees for years with no ill effects. This anomaly poses an important question, to which there are yet no answers, as to ‘why are there variable amounts of Hypoglycin-A in different sycamore trees’ plant material?’ This question is particularly pertinent when nearly 100 horses died in the UK in 2014 due to AM12. Suggestions have included that Hypoglycin-A levels may vary due to the time of year or due to different climatic conditions; however, these risk factors have not yet been confirmed, but research is ongoing.
New Test Available
A new test available from the Comparative Neuromuscular Diseases Laboratory at the Royal Veterinary College is available for the testing of seeds, seedlings and leaves for Hypoglycin A. Professor Richard Piercy, Professor of Comparative Neuromuscular Disease, said: “We’re really pleased to be able to launch our testing service for atypical myopathy. Through working with vets and owners in this way and with the support of The Horse Trust and ACT [Animal Care Trust], we hope to be able to improve the understanding of the condition and improve the welfare of horses.” Further details on the test are available from the Royal Veterinary College website.
| Sycamore seeds
||Sycamore leaves and seeds
Removal of Sycamore Seedlings
As the link of the sycamore seeds and seedlings being the cause of AM is relatively new, at this stage there are unfortunately still a lot of questions to be answered. One of the many research investigations being undertaken by the RVC is investigating the effects on ruminants. An important consideration is that Hypoglycin-A can have different effects in different species; for example, in rats the intoxication causes mainly liver damage and intestinal problems rather than causing the same clinical signs observed in horses. Therefore, we are currently not able to recommend the use of livestock to help graze sycamore seeds or seedlings.
Anecdotally, the use of sprays has achieved varying results. Again, this is another area that is being fully investigated by the RVC, and currently there are no specific recommendations to show a fully effective spray.
Research has found that seedlings contain a higher concentration level of the Hypoglycin-A in the leaves and a much lower concentration in the stalks. Mowing the seedlings will help to eliminate the most dangerous part of the seedlings, but it is imperative that the mown cuttings are collected at the time of mowing and not left on the pasture as the Hypoglycin-A is likely to remain in wilted plants and of course mown grass is a serious risk of causing colic. It may also be prudent to allow the field to rest for a few days before allowing the horses back on the land to graze. The amount and presence of Hypoglycin-A in seeds and seedlings does vary between trees and again the reasons for this are currently being investigated.
The BHS appreciates that the clearance of sycamore seeds and seedlings poses a huge task and headache to horse owners if removed by hand. With limited recommendations at present, until more conclusions have been ascertained from the studies, we understand it is frustrating but the BHS continues to liaise with the RVC and other experts and will update horse owners on developments as soon as we receive them.
Further advice on AM is available on the BHS website. Alternatively, you can contact the Welfare Team on 02476 840517 or firstname.lastname@example.org. If you have any concerns for the health of your horse, contact your veterinary surgeon immediately.
1. Votion DM et al. (2014) Identification of methylenecyclopropyl acetic acid in serum of European horses with atypical myopathy. Equine Veterinary Journal March 46(2) pg. 146-9.
2. Durham A. (2014) Seasonal pasture myopathy – an increasing threat. Equine Health Nov/Dec pg. 26-29.
3. Draper A. (2016) Should we cut down all sycamores? BEVA Congress Handbook of Presentations 7-10 Sep pg. 142-3.
4. Royal Veterinary College. (2017) Plant sample testing for Atypical Myopathy – owner information sheet. [Accessed 01.03.17].
5. Squirrell J. (2015) Sycamore, Acer pseudoplatanus. [Accessed 01.03.17].
6. Lemieux H et al. (2016) Mitochondrial function is altered in horse atypical myopathy. Mitochondrion Sep 30 pg. 35-41.
7. Westermann CM et al. (2016) Hypoglycin A concentrations in maple tree species in the Netherlands and the occurrence of atypical myopathy in horses. Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine May/June 30 (3) pg. 880-4.
8. Grὂndahl GB et al. (2015) Detection of the toxin Hypoglycin A in pastured horses and in the European sycamore maple tree (Acer Pseudoplatanus) during two outbreaks of atypical myopathy in Sweden. Equine Veterinary Journal. 47 Supplement 48:22.
9. Zuraw A et al. (2016) Equine atypical myopathy caused by hypoglycin A intoxication associated with ingestion of sycamore maple tree seeds. Equine Veterinary Journal July 48 (4) pg. 418-21.
10. Baise E et al. (2016) Samaras and seedlings of Acer pseudoplatanus are potential sources of hypoglycin A intoxication in atypical myopathy without necessarily inducing clinical signs. Equine Veterinary Journal 48 (4) pg. 414-17.
11. Zuraw A et al. (2016) Equine atypical myopathy caused by hypoglycin A intoxication associated with ingestion of sycamore maple tree seeds. Equine Veterinary Journal 48 (4) pg. 418-21.
12. Université de Liège (2014) Alert of the 28th of October 2014 – update 19/12/2014. [Accessed 02.03.17].